A Prequel to 1/6/2021: Was This When a Fighting Quaker Saved FDR and America??

A year ago last  week was not the only time there was a plot to take over the Capitol. A somewhat similar scheme was aimed at Franklin Roosevelt, to keep him from acting as president. It was stopped by, of all people, a retired general of Quaker heritage. There are many eerie and unsettling echoes of this “prequel” in our current state of heightened tension.

Smedley Butler, in uniform

Major General Smedley Butler, a career Marine who was a fierce fighter — twice awarded the Congressional Medal of Honor — and was of Pennsylvania Quaker stock. His grandfather, Smedley Darlington, was raised Quaker, and was one of the enthusiastic young Friends who joined the Union Army in the Civil War, as described in the popular 1863 song, “A Quaker Letter to Lincoln”:

Our dear young men are all aroused, so deeply they deplore

They’re joining “fighting [U. S. General] Joseph [Hooker]’s” band to end [i. e., win] “this cruel war.”
Back to his grandson Smedley Butler: In the Washington Post on January 14, 2021 this headline appeared:
Wealthy bankers and businessmen plotted to overthrow FDR. A retired general foiled it.
By Gillian Brockell.

The consternation had been growing in the months between Franklin D. Roosevelt’s election and his inauguration, but his elimination of the gold standard in April 1933 infuriated some of the country’s wealthiest men. Titans of banking and business worried that if U.S. currency wasn’t backed by gold, inflation could skyrocket and make their millions worthless. Why, they could end up as poor as most everyone else was during the Great Depression.

So, according to the sworn congressional testimony of a retired general, they decided to overthrow the government and install a dictator who was more business friendly. After all, they reasoned, that had been working well in Italy.

How close this fascist cabal got, and who exactly was in on it, are still subjects of historical debate. But as the dust settles after the pro-Trump attack on the U.S. Capitol, and as it becomes clearer how close lawmakers came to catastrophe, the similarities to the Business Plot are hard to ignore.

“The nation has never been at a potential brink as it was then up until, I think, now,” said Sally Denton, author of the book “The Plots against the President: FDR, A Nation in Crisis, and the Rise of the American Right.”
Smedley D. Butler was a highly decorated Marine Corps general who had received the Medal of Honor twice. He was beloved by his men before his retirement, and more so afterward when he spoke in support of the Bonus Army’s fight for early bonus payments for World War I service.
“He was wildly popular and was an outspoken critic of fascism and Mussolini at a time when there was really an impulse toward that throughout the world, including in the United States,” Denton said.
Sally Denton, a veteran investigative reporter

Given his opposition to fascism, Butler might not seem like a good fit for the job of coup leader, but his support from veterans was more important to the Wall Street plotters.

The “Bonus Army” in Washington. Veterans battered by the Great Depression, they didn’t want revolution, but what would today be called a “stimulus.” (Historical Society of Washington) (and Historical Society of Washington, D.C. /Historical Society of Washington, D.C.)

At the time, there were many more veterans than active-duty service members; if someone could summon them as a force of 500,000 to march on Washington, the government could fall without a shot being fired.

[in a more recent article, Denton elaborated on the social-political context:

In a climate of conspiracies and intrigues, and against the backdrop of charismatic dictators in the world such as Hitler and Mussolini, the sparks of anti-Rooseveltism ignited into full-fledged hatred. Many American intellectuals and business leaders saw nazism and fascism as viable models for the US.

The rise of Hitler and the explosion of the Nazi revolution, which frightened many European nations, struck a chord with prominent American elites and antisemites such as Charles Lindbergh and Henry Ford. Hitler’s elite Brownshirts – a mass body of party storm troopers separate from the 100,000-man German army – was a stark symbol to the powerless American masses. Mussolini’s Blackshirts – the military arm of his organization made up of 200,000 soldiers – were a potent image of strength to a nation that felt emasculated.

. . . America’s right wing was inspired to form its own paramilitary organizations. Militias sprung up throughout the land, their self-described “patriots” chanting: “This is despotism! This is tyranny!”

Today’s Proud Boys and Oath Keepers have nothing on their extremist forbears. In 1933, a diehard core of conservative veterans formed the Khaki Shirts in Philadelphia and recruited pro-Mussolini immigrants. The Silver Shirts was an apocalyptic Christian militia patterned on the notoriously racist Texas Rangers that operated in 46 states and stockpiled weapons. [More on the Silver Shirts here.]

The Gray Shirts of New York organized to remove “Communist college professors” from the nation’s education system, and the North Carolina-based White Shirts wore a Crusader cross and agitated for the takeover of Washington. JP Morgan Jr, one of the nation’s richest men, had secured a $100m loan to Mussolini’s government. He defiantly refused to pay income tax and implored his peers to join him in undermining FDR. . . .]

In the summer of 1933, a bond broker and American Legion member named Gerald MacGuire approached General Butler and tried to convince him that it would be in the Bonus Army veterans’ interests to demand their payments in gold. He then offered to send Butler and a group of veterans on a lavish speaking trip, all expenses paid, in support of the gold standard.
Butler was suspicious about where the money was coming from but strung MacGuire along over several months to glean more information. Eventually, MacGuire laid it all out: He was working for a group of mega-rich businessmen with access to $300 million to bankroll a coup.
They would plant stories in the press about Roosevelt being overwhelmed and in bad health. Once Butler’s army rolled in, a “Secretary of General Affairs” would be installed to handle the real governance, while Roosevelt would be reduced to cutting ribbons and such.
And they would take care of Butler, too. Additionally, they “offered college educations for his children and his mortgage paid off,” Denton said. “A lot of people would have taken it.”
In [a newsreel ] clip from Dec. 28, 1935,  Butler describes a “fascist plot” to overthrow President Franklin D. Roosevelt and seize the government. (Universal Studios)
But Butler wanted to know who these businessmen offering him money and power were. According to the BBC radio show “Document,” MacGuire told him they would announce themselves shortly. A few weeks later, news of a new conservative lobbying group called the American Liberty League broke. Its members included J.P. Morgan Jr., Irénée du Pont and the CEOs of General Motors, Birds Eye and General Foods, among others. Together they held near $40 billion in assets, Denton said — about $778 billion today.
Had Butler been a different sort of person and gone along with the plot, Denton thinks it would have been successful.
Instead, in the fall of 1934, he went to J. Edgar Hoover, head of what would become the FBI.
Congressional hearings were launched to investigate possible fascist sympathizers. Details of the plot soon leaked to the press, who mocked Butler and declared it all a “gigantic hoax.” If Butler wasn’t making it all up, journalists declared, then surely MacGuire was just a prankster fooling him.
The committee never released a report, but it told Congress it “had received evidence that certain persons had made an attempt to establish a fascist organization in this country. There is no question that these attempts were discussed, were planned, and might have been placed in execution when and if the financial backers deemed it expedient.”
Butler — who later published a [short] book, “War Is a Racket,” [NOTE: A full-length audiobook edition is available at no charge online here  — and the book text is online free here ] in which he lamented that all the military conflicts he had ever been involved in were fought to benefit “millionaires and billionaires” — was somewhat vindicated.
But he claimed that he had named names, and those names had been removed from his testimony that was released to the public.
“Like most committees, it has slaughtered the little and allowed the big to escape. The big shots weren’t even called to testify,” he said in a radio interview.
The committee maintained the names were kept under wraps until they could be investigated and verified. But no further investigation was ever conducted.
According to journalist John Buchanan, speaking to the BBC in 2007, that was probably because Roosevelt struck a deal with the backers of the plot: They could avoid treason charges — and possible execution — if they backed off their opposition to the New Deal. Denton thinks the press may have ignored the report at the urging of the government, which didn’t want the public to know how precarious things might have been.
Smedley Butler is an unlikely Quaker peace hero. Few Friends now remember him. But some who have gone beneath the simplistic versions know that the Friends heritage and its impulses pop up in unexpected places and at unexpected times.
Even after publishing War Is a Racket, Butler did not become a pacifist; more of an isolationist/anti-corporate imperialist: if somebody invaded the U.S., he would fight again. Otherwise, he wanted to  leave the world alone, and minimize what we now call the military-industrial complex.
As our 2023-2024 political ordeal plays out, we will need other generals like Butler, with or without Quaker connections. The authoritarian forces are infiltrating the U. S. military, hoping to shift units or commanders to their side when the next crunch comes. (A new Pentagon report on this is here for free download.)


4 thoughts on “A Prequel to 1/6/2021: Was This When a Fighting Quaker Saved FDR and America??”

  1. I joined Friends 40 years ago because friends of mine were speaking about the vietNam war. I found integrity and deep faith that I hadent found in the church of my childhood. I have always been against any form of physical violence. However over my 77 years I’ve watched how I seemingly kind people can be come followers of the the loudest and finically backed evil hearted. Men. We even elected one who wasn’t up to the job thank goodness. However his poisonous voice still rings true to many. I’m heartbroken.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.