I won’t say the situation is hopeless; but “bleak” does not do it justice. And barring the rise of some unpredictable earthquake comparable to the Selma voting rights movement, the new southern white supremacist GOP status quo looks from here in Carolina as if it will be very difficult to dislodge. Contra Raines, I could see it taking as many generations as the last one to dismantle.
Anti-Disestablishmentarianism: The Word for Southern Marriage HoldoutsDo kids still joke about learning to spell “anti-disestablishentarianism”? I used to think it was a fake, something made up, like Mary Poppins’s “supercalifragilisticexpialidocious.” But no! It was real. And in fact, I just realized that TODAY, for the very first time ever, I can use the term in … Continue reading Anti-Disestablishmentarianism: The Word for Southern Marriage Holdouts
A Circuit Clerk in Mississippi resigned her post rather than issue marriage licenses to same sex couples.
Linda Barnette said in a letter of resignation, effective on June 30, 2015, that
“The Supreme Court’s decision violates my core values as a Christian,” she wrote. “My final authority is the Bible. I cannot in all good conscience issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples under my name because the Bible clearly teaches that homosexuality is contrary to God’s plan and purpose for marriage and family. . . .”
Acquaintances said Barnette’s husband is a pastor who worked with Billy Graham Ministries for many years.
“I choose to obey God rather than man,” Barnette wrote.
Linda-Barnette
Linda Barnette, former Circuit Clerk of Grenada County, Mississippi.
I cite this letter to pay Barnette public respect. She had been Circuit Clerk, for 24 years. But she followed her conscience, peacefully but clearly, out the door.
That’s what Christians and Quakers are supposed to do.
Her witness is honorable. It is also rare. And it won’t slow the issuance of same sex marriage licenses in the state by much, if at all.
Yes, the Same sex marriage forces in Massachusetts and elsewhere have deployed a secret weapon that is proving irresistible. And it does not involve locking opponents up, burning their churches, banning their books and movies — none of that paranoid silliness.
Even so, it’s real, and it works. I’ve seen it in operation close up, and am ready to to spill the beans:
It’s NORMALITY.
Legal same sex marriage expands the realm of day to day family life, with all its routines: juggling work & child care; homework, dentists, soccer, adolescence; fix the dinner and clean up that room. Plus the usual conflicts, which sometimes lead to divorce. Which is sad, but also NORMAL.
That’s what life is for legal same sex families. Flagrant, flamboyant, in-your-face NORMAL.
And over time, I haven’t seen anything that can beat it.
Together the four Supreme Court dissents make up a longer body of text than the decision. So for readability I am presenting them in three sizes:
First, the “Mini” or “Executive Summary” version, select quotes that add up to almost 4000 words.
Next, The Medium size, a fuller selection of the texts, which comes to almost 12,000 words.
And finally, at this link, one can read the dissents in their entirety, at about 19,000 words. (To find them, scroll down past the initial, “Opinion of the Court” section.)
Supreme-court-rainbow
Again, I have refrained from editorializing here, though as various commentators in the media have already said, that was not so easy. Many provocative statements and assertions are here, and they will rightly evoke extended discussion here and elsewhere.
The Dissents are presented in order of “rank”: Roberts, the Chief Justice, goes first, followed by Scalia, the longest-serving among the group; then Thomas, and finally the newbie Alito. That’s how they are presented here.