Spoiler Alert: Atticus Finch Isn’t Perfect. (I Can Live With That. Can You?)

Spoiler Alert: Atticus Finch Isn’t Perfect.
(I Can Live With That. Can You?)

imageSo:  in the NY Times review of “Go Set A Watchman,”  Harper Lee’s new/old novel,  we learn that Atticus Finch, the sainted father figure of “To Kill A Mockingbird,” shares some of the ugly racism of his place (small-town Alabama), and times (the mid-1950s), 20 years after the “Mockingbird” events.To_Kill_a_Mockingbird-Cover

And already, many fans of the first novel are freaking out:  

Say It Ain’t So! First Woody Allen, then Bill Cosby, now even Atticus– are there no heroes left at all??? (Any day now, I expect to see some shameful disclosures about Sponge Bob Square  Pants.)

Some are insisting they won’t go near the new novel, to preserve their sacred memories of an iconic father/crusader-for-justice figure, who looks just like Gregory Peck.

I sympathize: the “Mockingbird” movie always turns me into a blubbering fool, and I STILL want to be Atticus/Peck when I grow up. Who would willingly  put all that at risk?

But I won’t easily be joining the ranks of the shocked & disillusioned when I follow Miss Jean Louise (tho she’ll always be Scout to me) on her fateful journey back home as a grown woman.

I’ll hold off on a pre-emptive literary judgment on the novel itself til I read it (counting down the hours); but as a slice drawn from actual history & life, the good Atticus/bad Atticus (or as I prefer, the Easy-Simple Atticus vs the Complex-More Human Atticus) is a no-brainer.

See, I’ve BTDT– Been There  & Done That.  For instance (one of many) I learned long ago that the Martin Luther King I shared a jail cell with in Selma, Alabama, had earlier faked and plagiarized most of the dissertation that gained him the title of “Doctor.”  And further, that this dauntless crusader against the public immorality of American racism & militarism had a private sexual morality that departed widely from  his professed Christian values.

Many other names  could be added here. And for some of them, the failings disclosed have indeed  been disqualifying for membership in my personal pantheon. But for some others –and Dr. King  tops this list– the sins complicate but do not negate the achievements and sacrifices.

Yes, Dr. King was definitely a sinner, but when he took that bullet in Memphis, he had NOT turned into a fraud or a sellout. He remains a hero for me, a complex one. Nothing I’ve yet learned has overturned  that verdict.

BTW if you want more about this judgment, here are my two books that pursue it:  Selma 1965: The March That Changed The South

Also   Eating Dr. King’s Dinner

Similarly high on my list, even tho he is entirely fictional, is Atticus Finch, and he’s been there for fifty years.  Will the sins to be revealed in the pages of Go Set A Watchman prove fatal to my regard for him?

Well, let me read it and get back to you.

But even before cracking open the book, I have to admit — when it comes to Atticus Finch, I have prejudices too.

[ P.S. I did read the book. My review is here. ]

2 thoughts on “Spoiler Alert: Atticus Finch Isn’t Perfect. (I Can Live With That. Can You?)”

  1. Perhaps a closer analogy to Finch than MLK Jr would be Thomas Watson (1856-1922), the Georgia politician who began his career as an egalitarian Populist denouncing lynching. He changed his views on race early in the 20th century, and ended his career as a Democratic racist demagogue whose inflammatory journalism helped to bring about the lynching of Leo Frank in 1915.

    1. Steve, Tom Watson is a good example. But I’m hoping that Atticus doesn’t turn out to be THAT bad. I’ll be traveling when my copy of “Watchman” arrives, but I should have it read by week’s end, and will then have more definite responses. I hope the national conversation about all the issues the book raises, echoes, reflects & refracts will be vigorous and spicy. This is just the summer for it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.