War Notes: Russian Jewish Community facing “dark clouds” over Ukraine war

Moscow’s ex-chief rabbi warns of ‘dark clouds’ for Russian Jews

Issued on:


Jerusalem (AFP) –
Moscow’s former chief rabbi now living in exile in Israel warned Thursday of “dark clouds on the horizon” for Russian Jews, as ties between the two countries deteriorate over the Ukraine war.

Pinchas Goldschmidt, who left Russia in March over opposition to the conflict, told reporters that “the Jewish community was pressured… to openly support the war. Our community did not support the war.”

“The situation is worrying” and there are “many dark clouds on the horizon” for Russian Jews, he said, adding that their “security and future… is dependent on Israel-Russia relations”.

Israel has been trying to walk a cautious line in order to maintain ties with Moscow — seen as crucial to preserving the Jewish state’s ability to carry out air strikes in neighbouring Syria, where Russian forces are present.

“Right now, it would be impossible for me to return,” the Swiss-born rabbi told an online briefing, adding: “If I would have (remained) the chief rabbi of Moscow, I wouldn’t be able to speak out openly without endangering my community.”

“I decided to stay in exile until the political situation will change.”

Following the February 24 invasion, then Israeli premier Naftali Bennett withheld criticism of Russian President Vladimir Putin’s actions and stressed the need for close ties with Moscow.

But Bennett’s successor Yair Lapid has condemned the Russian invasion.

Analysts say Lapid’s rhetoric has partly driven Moscow’s move to close the Russian branch of the Jewish Agency, which processes the immigration of Jews from the diaspora to Israel.

Lapid has warned Moscow that the closure would be a “serious event” threatening bilateral ties.

The Kremlin has said the move should not be “politicised”, calling it a purely legal matter.

According to the Jewish Agency, 16,000 Russian Jews have immigrated to Israel since the invasion began.

‘Fear of rising anti-Semitism’

Goldschmidt estimated that more than 30,000 other dual passport holders had left Russia for Israel since February 24.

Jews were leaving Russia in high numbers partly over fears of a new “Iron Curtain — that one day (it) will be impossible to leave”, the rabbi said, articulating what he described as concern among Jews that Putin’s government could ban outbound travel.

He said Moscow’s moves against the Jewish Agency, among other incidents, had fostered “fear of rising anti-Semitism”.

Some experts have attributed Russia’s threats against the agency as part of an attempt to slow mass emigration.

“If Russia wants to stop the brain drain of its best scientists and creative class, the best way to do this is not by closing the Jewish Agency, but by stopping this war,” Goldschmidt said.

At a preliminary hearing on Thursday, a Moscow court set an August 19 trial date for the Russian justice ministry’s case against the agency, which has been accused of unspecified legal violations.

The Jewish Agency began working in Russia in 1989.

More than one million of Israel’s 9.4 million residents today have roots in the former Soviet Union.

One thought on “War Notes: Russian Jewish Community facing “dark clouds” over Ukraine war”

  1. All my Jewish relatives in Ukraine were killed by Ukrainian Nazis.

    When Biden funded the arming and training of Ukrainian Nazis again starting in 2014, condemned by 100% of Congressional Democrats (and with defunding of the BidenNazis sponsored by Rep. John Conyers on June 11, 2015), the killings started again as well. And they are now 1,500 monuments to Ukrainian Nazis in Ukraine, including a giant statue of Stephan Bandera in Lviv, with Nazi symbols adorning.

    In 2015, Ukraine passed a law making it a felony to criticize Ukrainian Nazis, and to mention their killing of Jews.

    The four pro-Nazi leaders of the Charlottesville riots were, according to the FBI in their indictment, all trained by Ukrainian Nazis. All of the recent synagogue shooters and bombers maintain that they were inspired by Ukrainian Nazis.

    In May, Zelensky charged that two of his major generals, both pro-Nazis, including the leader of the Secret Police, were being demoted because they had committed treason, as had many others. However, none of them were arrested, or even dismissed, even though they had, according to Zelensky, committed treason.

    Stories are complicated.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.