Wikipedia vs Russia: The War comes Out in the Open on the Web

[NOTE: In my view, Wikipedia is just about the best thing in the web. I consult it almost every day, donate when they ask, and respect what seems to be their increasing credibility and comprehensiveness as a source of reliable information.

But “reliable information” is a hotly contested commodity, and in many places part of a larger battlefield. And a much more important indicator of Wikipedia’s importance than my regard, is the fire they’re drawing from state actors and other militants who want to bend its information to their partisan narratives and disinformation.

There are many such skirmishes going on. Wikipedia’s conflict is one such battlefront. It’s increasingly important, and the stakes are high. And getting higher.]

Russian Court fines Wikipedia for article on Ukraine– – – – –

April 13, 2023

A Moscow court on Thursday again fined Wikipedia for a Russianlanguage article it refused to remove about Russias invasion of Ukraine, the latest in a series of government moves to silence objective reporting or criticism of the war and restrict the Russian publics access to information.

The court fined Wikimedia Foundation, the nonprofit that runs the free, publiclyedited online encyclopedia, 2 million rubles ($24,464) for not removing a Wikipedia article titled “Russian occupation of the Zaporizhzhia region, a reference to one of four Ukrainian provinces that Russia annexed last September. Most countries have condemned the annexation, as well as that by Russia in 2014 of Ukraines Crimean Peninsula, as illegal.

The state Tass news agency said the Wikimedia Foundation had failed to heed the demands of Russias state communications watchdog Roskomnadzor to remove articles containing “false information.” Tass said a Wikipedia representative asked the court to reject the removal demand as vague.

President Vladimir Putin in recent years has increased his crackdown on criticism and factual reporting that doesnt correspond to his governments views or versions of events. The crackdown has widened since his troops invaded Ukraine on Feb. 24, 2022, focusing especially on information and dissent against what he calls Russias “special military operation” in the neighboring country.

Through Roskomnadzor, his government has also tried, with mixed success, to technically limit Western news reports that can be seen in Russia. The BBC and some Voice of America sites are among those it has blocked but which Russians can access using virtual private networks.

This is not the first time Wikipedia has been fined for refusing to delete “false” information about the war in Ukraine.

Last week, the same Moscow court issued a fine of 800,000 rubles ($9,785) to the Wikimedia Foundation for not removing materials linked to a song by a Russian rock band called Psychea, which Russian authorities consider to be extremist.

In November 2022, the organization was fined 2 million rubles for refusing to delete “false” information in seven Wikipedia articles about the special military operation, including information about atrocities in Bucha and the destruction of Mariupol’s theater.

In a statement Thursday, Wikimedia’s senior legal manager, Leighanna Mixter, said the organization has not taken down the disputed content and will continue to challenge the rulings as without foundation. She said the “the steady stream of takedown orders” Wikimedia has received in recent months challenge information that is “wellsourced and in line with applicable Wikipedia policies — improved by Wikipedia volunteer editors with more citations and uptodate information.”

Wikimedia has two active appeals for fines related to takedown notices for topics regarding the invasion of Ukraine — and the latest case “does not present any new legal issues,” she said.

“These orders are part of an ongoing effort by the Russian government to limit the spread of reliable, wellsourced information in the country,” she added, asserting that Wikimedia would resist all attempts to “try to curb free knowledge.”

A Wikipedia page on the issue notes, “Since the early 2010s, Russian Wikipedia and its editors have experienced numerous and increasing threats of nationwide blocks and countrywide enforcement of blacklisting by the Russian government, as well as several attempts to censor pages, spread propaganda, and disinformation.”

Tass said Roskomnadzor will label Wikimedia in search engines as a violator of Russian law, and more action against specific articles is planned.

AP Technology Writer Frank Bajak contributed from Boston.


4 thoughts on “Wikipedia vs Russia: The War comes Out in the Open on the Web”

  1. All true, but is only half the story. The Pentagon and the White House employees dozens of people to scrub the web, change Wikipedia entries, send emails, all in a relentless campaign of disinformation.

      1. Bill, one of the very large but unheralded units at Ft. (Bragg-Soon-to-be-Ft.Liberty) is the Fourth Psychological Operations Group, and they are ALL about it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.